(Bloomberg) — New York Attorney General Letitia James asked a judge to throw out former President Donald Trump’s lawsuit seeking to block her civil investigation into asset valuations by his real-estate business.
James, who has been probing the Manhattan-based Trump Organization for possible fraud since 2019, argued in a federal court filing Wednesday in Albany that a judge overseeing an earlier clash in state court has already cleared the investigation and repeatedly ordered the company to comply.
The fight over the attorney general’s investigation heated up in December after she subpoenaed Trump and two of his children, Donald Trump Jr. and Ivanka Trump, to testify under oath and hand over documents. The Trumps earlier asked the judge in the state court case to block those subpoenas.
“In the three years that we have been conducting this investigation, the Trump Organization and its principles have never challenged the legality of the investigation, until now, when Mr. Trump himself was subpoenaed to testify,” James said in a statement. “We will not be deterred by frivolous lawsuits.”
Read More: Trump’s Top 7 Asset Troubles, From Penthouse Size to Club Fees
Trump sued James in December, alleging the Democrat was conducting the probe to attract media attention and advance her political career. His lawsuit cited critical comments James had made about Trump, arguing her probe was a foregone conclusion because she disagreed with his politics.
But state law doesn’t require prosecutors to be “entirely neutral and detached,” and prosecutorial discretion is “particularly deferential at the investigative stage,” James said in Wednesday’s filing. The attorney general also cited an appeals court ruling holding that it is permissible to probe high-profile targets that attract media attention, as a deterrence.
“Once again, Letitia James fails to address her egregious and unethical conduct in her weak response to our complaint,” Alina Habba, a lawyer for Trump, said in an email after the motion to dismiss was filed.
James also said in her filing that Trump’s company has already legitimized the investigation by handing over 900,000 documents and bringing in more than a dozen current and former employees for testimony. The company also has submitted to third-party supervision of its compliance, she said.
“In a complete about-face, plaintiffs contend here that the investigation was actually never justified or lawful in the first place,” James said in the filing.
The Trump Organization has balked before at complying with James, prompting her to sue in August 2020 to enforce an initial set of seven subpoenas. The judge in that case has repeatedly ordered Trump’s company to fully comply.
Eric Trump, one of the former president’s sons and an executive vice president at the Trump Organization, was deposed by state investigators in October 2020 after fighting in court to delay the questioning.
(Updates to add comment from Trump’s lawyer.)
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com
©2022 Bloomberg L.P.
