U.S. Holds Firm on Russian Demands With Ukraine Tensions High

(Bloomberg) — The U.S. has provided its written response to Russia’s security demands, Secretary of State Antony Blinken said, the latest step in the high-stakes diplomacy over Moscow’s buildup of more than 100,000 troops on Ukraine’s border. 

The document delivered in Moscow by Ambassador John Sullivan on Wednesday sets out “a serious diplomatic path forward,” Blinken told reporters in Washington. “We are open to dialogue, we prefer diplomacy. It remains up to Russia to decide how to respond. We are ready either way.” 

But the top U.S. diplomat also made clear that the report largely sticks to points presented by the U.S. and NATO allies in recent weeks: It rejects Russia’s demand that NATO redraw its borders and close its door to Ukraine’s potential membership in the future, instead offering suggestions such as arms control talks and greater transparency over troop movements and military exercises.

“We will uphold the principle of NATO’s open door,” Blinken said, repeating the U.S. and European position that Russia shouldn’t get to dictate which nations join the military alliance. “We also do lay out areas where we believe that together we could actually advance security for everyone, including for Russia.”

Blinken said he expects to speak with Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov in “coming days.” The U.S. won’t make the document public, Blinken said.

Why Russia-Ukraine Tensions Are So Hard to Defuse: QuickTake

It wasn’t clear if Russian President Vladimir Putin’s government would respond immediately to the proposal, which was delivered late in the day in Moscow. Russian officials have repeatedly rejected assertions that they intend to invade Ukraine. 

Russia has said it will decide whether to continue diplomatic efforts with the U.S. and its allies based on the written answers. Moscow has said previously that the talks the U.S. has offered publicly on limiting missiles and reducing risks around military maneuvers were positive but not sufficient to address its security concerns.

The remarks by Blinken were echoed by NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg, who spoke to reporters in Brussels after the alliance delivered its own response to Moscow that struck similar themes.

“We are prepared to listen to Russia’s concerns and engage in a real conversation on how to uphold and strengthen fundamental principles of European security that we have all signed up to,” Stoltenberg said. “This is about respecting nations and their right to choose their own path, and that has not changed.”

But he also emphasized that the North Atlantic Treaty Organization is moving forward with steps to take in case of attack, praising the U.S. decision to put 8,500 troops based in the U.S. on high alert for possible deployment to NATO allies. 

While the U.S. and its allies have promised “massive sanctions” if Russia sends troops into Ukraine, there has been disagreement behind the scenes over how to respond, particularly to a Russian action short of full-blown war. 

Read more: Germany Sought Energy Exemption in Russia Finance Sanctions 

Germany has pushed for an exemption for the energy sector if there is a move to block Russian banks from clearing U.S. dollar transactions, according to documents seen by Bloomberg. People familiar with recent discussions said other major western European nations hold similar views, given Europe’s dependence on Russian natural gas supplies. 

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz has also rejected sending weapons to Ukraine and is holding out on allowing Estonia to transfer Cold War-era equipment to the country. Instead, Germany has offered to finance and train people for a field hospital and send over 5,000 protective helmets.

Pressed about those disagreements, Blinken continued to emphasize public unity on punishing Moscow in case of war. 

“The steps that we will take together, swiftly, will go directly to things that President Putin cares directly about” including finance and technology, he said. 

Blinken added that the U.S. is in discussions with governments around the world on “surging” their energy production and delivery capacities in event of a crisis. The developments comes after Brent crude hit $90 for the first time since 2014. With crude supplies tight, traders say a $10 per barrel spike is at stake if Russia invades Ukraine. 

Oil Could Spike $10 Higher in Event of Invasion: Markets Live

U.S. officials continue to say a Russian attack could come by mid-February. 

In a sign of the continuing high tensions, on Wednesday a top official of the pro-Kremlin ruling party who’s also a senior member of the Senate, Andrey Turchak, suggested Russia could send “certain weapons” to the separatists it backs in Ukraine’s eastern Donbas region. Openly arming the separatists would undermine Russia’s claims — rejected by Ukraine and the West — that it’s not a party to the conflict.

Even as diplomacy continued in recent days, the Kremlin continued its buildup of troops, tanks and equipment near Ukraine’s borders, with a major deployment to Belarus for exercises. Russia has said the forces aren’t a threat to anyone but has refused Western calls to reverse the buildup.

For now, it appears the two sides are keeping the diplomatic track going, said Olga Rebro, an expert from the Moscow State Institute of International Relations who is affiliated with the Valdai foreign policy discussion club.

“The danger is that part of this negotiating process may be demonstrations of resolve which can lead to mutual escalation,” she said. 

(Updates with comments by Blinken, Stoltenberg starting in second paragraph.)

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Close Bitnami banner
Bitnami